WHERE IT STARTED
FIRST SEEN: c. 2012-2013 · GOING FOR: About 13 years
First cases appeared in the United States around 2012-2013 as Kickstarter projects failed to deliver; the FTC brought its first action in June 2015.
Kickstarter (2009), Indiegogo and GoFundMe (2010) created a new way to raise money from strangers, and fraud followed within a few years: creators who took pledges and never delivered, and charity-style appeals built on invented stories. The FTC's first crowdfunding case was against board-game creator Erik Chevalier in 2015; its iBackPack case (2019) involved more than $800,000 raised for a product never made. The most famous personal-appeal case was 'Paying It Forward' (2017), in which a New Jersey couple and a homeless veteran invented a roadside good-deed story and raised $400,000 from 14,000 donors.
HOW IT WORKS
Reward-based fraud: a creator posts a product or game with slick renders, collects pledges, then spends the money on personal expenses and posts excuses until the campaign is abandoned. Donation-based fraud: a campaigner invents or exaggerates a hardship (illness, disaster, a heroic stranger), amplifies it through media, and withdraws the funds. Platforms refund some donors from their own guarantees, but the money is usually gone. Prosecution comes under general theft, wire-fraud or deceptive-advertising law.
A campaign with no verifiable identity, address or track recordA story that spreads fast through media but cannot be checkedRewards promised years out with repeated delays and no prototypesCampaign organiser is not the beneficiary and controls all withdrawalsFunds raised far above the stated need with no plan for the surplus
HOW USEFUL IT IS TO CRIMINALS
A campaign page costs nothing and a viral story can raise hundreds of thousands in days, with payouts before any delivery. Platforms police lightly and refund donors themselves in high-profile cases, so few frauds are reported to police; the FTC has brought only a handful of actions and judgments are usually suspended.
THE DAMAGE IT HAS CAUSED
$800,000+
Largest FTC crowdfunding case (iBackPack); no annual total published — FTC, May 2019
No body publishes a total; the best-known cases are the $400,000 'Paying It Forward' hoax (2017) and the $800,000 iBackPack campaign (2019). The wider harm is to trust: genuine medical and disaster appeals lose donors after each exposed hoax.
$400,000 Raised by the 'Paying It Forward' hoax from 14,000 donors, GoFundMe's largest fraud at the time (Burlington County Prosecutor via NBC News, 2018)
$800,000+ Raised by iBackPack, the FTC's largest reward-crowdfunding case (FTC, May 2019)
1,246 Backers of the first campaign the FTC acted on (2015) (FTC, Jun 2015)
WHO USES IT MOST
MOST OF ALL: 🇺🇸 United States ▸
The major platforms are American and every significant prosecution or FTC action (Chevalier, iBackPack, 'Paying It Forward') has been in the United States.
United States (platforms, cases)United Kingdom (Action Fraud crowdfunding reports)Canada (GoFundMe appeal cases)Australia (fake cancer appeals)India (fake medical fundraisers)
GOVERNMENTS LINKED TO IT
No government is documented as using this method.
NOTABLE PEOPLE WHO USED IT — RANKED BY PROFILE ORDER (NOT BY AMOUNT)
#1 Mark D'Amico and Katelyn McClure CONVICTED (D'AMICO 5 YEARS STATE PRISON 2020 AND 27 MONTHS FEDERAL; MCCLURE 1 YEAR FEDERAL 2022)REPORT PENDING
Over $400,000 from about 14,000 donors · 2017-2018
New Jersey couple who, with Johnny Bobbitt, fabricated the 'Paying It Forward' story of a homeless veteran giving his last $20 for gas; spent the money on a BMW, an RV and casinos.
SOURCE: CBS News Philadelphia and NBC10, 2019-2022
#2 Johnny Bobbitt Jr. CONVICTED (PROBATION, STATE 2019 AND FEDERAL)REPORT PENDING
$25,000 restitution ordered · 2017-2018
Homeless Marine veteran at the centre of the same GoFundMe hoax.
SOURCE: CBS News Philadelphia, 2019
#3 Erik Chevalier (The Forking Path) SETTLED (FTC ORDER, 11 JUN 2015)REPORT PENDING
$122,000 from 1,246 backers; $111,794 judgment (suspended) · 2012-2013
Kickstarter creator of 'The Doom That Came to Atlantic City' who spent backers' money on rent and a move; the FTC's first crowdfunding case.
SOURCE: FTC press release, 11 Jun 2015
#4 Douglas Monahan (iBackPack of Texas) CIVIL (FTC COMPLAINT MAY 2019; SETTLEMENT WITH CROWDFUNDING BAN)REPORT PENDING
Over $800,000 raised · 2015-2017
Raised money on Indiegogo and Kickstarter for a battery-equipped backpack that was never delivered; the FTC alleged the funds went to personal use.
SOURCE: FTC v. iBackPack of Texas, 2019-2020
SOURCES
CBS News Philadelphia, 'Homeless good Samaritan gets probation in GoFundMe scam', 2019
NBC News, 'Arrests in GoFundMe homeless good Samaritan scam', Nov 2018
NBC10 Philadelphia, Bobbitt sentencing, 2022
FTC press release, 'Crowdfunding Project Creator Settles FTC Charges of Deception', 11 Jun 2015
FTC, iBackPack of Texas case, 2019-2020
Newsweek, GoFundMe refunds all donors, 2018